Skip to main content
Indiana Electric Cooperatives

Deregulation would cost Hoosier households more.

Certain out-of-state groups are seeking changes that would let large corporations and data centers buy their electricity from someone other than their local utility, sometimes referred to as "retail choice." Households could not switch. They would keep paying for the grid those businesses leave behind. Their model is Michigan, where the average residential rate is 26% higher (true value 25.5%).

40%

more paid by residential customers in the 19 states and jurisdictions with retail choice than in fully regulated states

What would your energy rate be?

Use this calculator to compare your monthly electric energy rate with what the same electricity would cost in states that deregulated their electric markets.

1Enter how much electricity you use each month

You can find your monthly kilowatt-hours on your electric bill, or choose the Indiana average below.

kilowatt-hours (kWh)
Indiana co-ops
Average electric cooperative
$157.29
per month
2Guess the Michigan bill
What do you think a Michigan household would pay each month for the same 1,000 kWh?

Drag the slider to your guess, then tap "Lock in my guess" to see how close you are.

$157 per month
3See how your energy rate compares

The same usage in three restructured states

Michigan
"Limited" retail choice since 2008
$200.10
20.03¢ per kWh
+$42.81 more than average Indiana co-op
Illinois
Deregulated in 1997, all customer classes
$176.90
17.67¢ per kWh
+$19.61 more than average Indiana co-op
Ohio
Deregulated in 1999, all customer classes
$169.60
16.90¢ per kWh
+$12.31 more than average Indiana co-op

Your monthly energy charge, state by state

What the Michigan difference adds up to at your usage

Per month
$42.81
Per year
$514
10 years
$5,137

What deregulation means for rural communities

Even if cooperatives are "exempted" from deregulation, rural communities would be worse off.

Loss of economic development

A business comparing a site where it could pick its power supplier with a rural site where it could not may lean toward the first. Rural communities could lose projects they would otherwise compete for.

Cost shifting

Cooperatives share Indiana’s transmission grid and wholesale power market with every other utility. When large customers stop paying their share of the power plants built to serve them, those costs fall on the customers who remain, and they can reach the shared system that rural communities rely on. The next section shows how that shift works.

Weaken long-term planning and reliability

The proposed legislation would require utility planners to leave departed customers out of their planning, which weakens long-term planning and efforts to maintain a safe and reliable grid.

How cost shifting works

The proposals in front of Indiana would open the market only to large businesses. That will shift costs from large customers to homeowners and small businesses.

Who benefits?

Big business, data centers, and other industries using 1 megawatt or more

Who pays?

Every household, small business, and family farm

Illustration of an Indiana electric system: a power plant and transmission towers. Homes and a farm are served through a substation and local distribution lines. A factory and a data center connect to the transmission lines through their own substation. Gold coins show each customer's share of the power plant's cost. Power plant Transmission lines Substation Distribution lines Substation Farm Homes Factory Data center SWITCHED SWITCHED COST UNCHANGED
Each coin is a share of the power plant's cost

Today, every customer shares the cost of the power plant that serves the whole system.

Factories and data centers using 1 megawatt or more could buy power elsewhere. Homes and farms could not.

They still use the same infrastructure, and still pay for delivery.

The power plant still costs the same. Because they leave the regulated system, their share moves onto your bill.

Michigan's cautionary tale

Michigan capped retail choice at 10 percent of utility sales in 2008. It is the closest example of the approach now proposed in Indiana.

10%

Michigan's cap on retail choice, set in 2008 and full since 2009

5,101

customers waiting to join, nearly as many as the 5,517 now participating (2025).

26%

higher residential rate than Indiana: 20.03¢ vs. 15.96¢ per kWh (2025)

Participating
5,514
Waiting
5,101

Average residential rate, Michigan and Indiana, 2001 to 2025

Texas's reliability disaster

In February 2021, Winter Storm Uri brought Texas's deregulated grid within minutes of total collapse.

4:37

Less than five minutes from a complete statewide blackout

4.5M+

Texans lost power, some for up to four days in freezing temperatures

246

Deaths confirmed by the state, most from hypothermia

Why the power plants failed

  1. 1

    Lack of investment in weatherizing generators. Federal investigators found the leading cause was power plants and fuel supplies that had not been prepared for freezing weather.

  2. 2

    A deregulated market has little accountability for reliability. Texas's deregulated market pays generators only for the electricity they sell. In a deregulated market, the state has little accountability to ensure power generation is reliable.

  3. 3

    Power providers were warned 10 years before Winter Storm Uri this would happen. After a 2011 freeze, federal regulators recommended the same preparations. Without a requirement, most were never made.

Why Indiana's model works

Planning for the long term

Utilities file integrated resource plans with the Indiana Utility Regulatory Commission (IURC) that look 20 years ahead and account for every customer on the system.

Focused on reliability

Each year, the IURC reviews reliability reports on whether there is enough power to meet demand, and utilities present their summer and winter reliability plans to the IURC.

Delivering results

Below Nat’l
Average Rates

15.96¢ per kWh for Indiana residential customers in 2025, compared with the 17.23¢ national average

99.98%
Reliability

average service availability across Indiana's cooperatives, 2025

Indiana's model holds utilities accountable for affordable, reliable power for every Hoosier.

Join the Grassroots Network

Become an advocate and take action today

Sign up for the Grassroots Network

Or visit goiec.org/TakeAction

Sources and notes
  • U.S. Energy Information Administration, Electricity Data Browser, 2025 annual average residential retail prices: Indiana 15.96¢/kWh, Michigan 20.03¢/kWh, Illinois 17.67¢/kWh, Ohio 16.90¢/kWh. Residential customers in the 19 retail choice states and jurisdictions pay an average of 21.76¢/kWh vs. 15.54¢/kWh in fully regulated states, a difference of 40 percent (IEC analysis of the same data). Annual series for Indiana and Michigan, 2001–2025. National average residential rate 17.23¢/kWh; Indiana's rate is the lowest in the East North Central region (Illinois, Indiana, Michigan, Ohio, and Wisconsin). Electric Power Annual 2025, Table 2.10
  • Indiana Electric Cooperatives, 2025 Residential Billing Survey (July 2025): average monthly bill across Indiana's distribution cooperatives of $157.29 at 1,000 kWh, $274.69 at 2,000 kWh, and $391.70 at 3,000 kWh (fixed, energy, and tracker charges; excludes taxes and fees). Bills at other usage levels are interpolated between these points. At the usage entered in the calculator, the average cooperative bill works out to an effective rate of 15.73¢ per kWh (the monthly bill divided by kWh used).
  • Bill calculator method: the Michigan, Illinois, and Ohio figures are each state's 2025 average residential rate multiplied by the usage entered (U.S. Energy Information Administration). The Indiana figure is the average cooperative member bill at that usage (IEC 2025 Residential Billing Survey). All calculator figures exclude taxes and other fees. The yearly and 10-year Michigan differences hold today's rates constant.
  • Michigan Public Service Commission, "Michigan's Electric Choice Program Remains Fully Subscribed in 2024," January 31, 2025 (5,517 participating customers; approximately 5,101 queued); Michigan Public Act 286 of 2008 (10 percent cap).
  • Retail choice legislation as introduced in the Indiana General Assembly, January 8, 2026: nonresidential customers of 1 MW or more, new or existing, with aggregation permitted; starting cap of at least 20 percent of weather-normalized retail sales, adjustable upward only; single sites over 75 MW excluded from the cap; no exit or transition fee; utility resource plans exclude competitive-supply loads.
  • FERC, NERC, and Regional Entity Staff, "The February 2021 Cold Weather Outages in Texas and the South Central United States," November 2021; University of Texas at Austin Energy Institute, "The Timeline and Events of the February 2021 Texas Electric Grid Blackouts" (4 minutes 37 seconds from statewide blackout, per ERCOT); Texas Department of State Health Services (246 confirmed storm-related deaths; hypothermia the leading cause). More than 4.5 million Texans lost power, some for up to four days. Federal recommendations following the February 2011 cold weather event were largely voluntary and not implemented.
  • Indiana planning and reliability oversight: integrated resource planning under the Indiana Utility Regulatory Commission's rule at 170 IAC 4-7 (20-year planning horizon); the commission's annual reliability reports and its summer and winter reliability presentations from utilities.
  • Cooperative reliability: IEC aggregation of Indiana distribution cooperatives' 2025 Form 7 reports (99.98 percent average service availability).
  • Cost-shift illustration: simplified for demonstration. The departing customer continues to pay regulated delivery charges; the shift described applies to fixed generation and planning costs.
Indiana Electric Cooperatives Indiana Electric Cooperatives represents Indiana's electric cooperatives serving 1.3 million Hoosiers in 89 of Indiana's 92 counties.